Paper Details  
 
   

Has Bibliography
6 Pages
1534 Words

 
   
   
    Filter Topics  
 
     
   
 

On the Relative Intelligence of Women A Review of Two Essays

During times in which there is increased social concern over the relative equality of men and women in various areas of study, there is a common desire to determine whether there is an appreciable difference in intelligence in relation to gender. Two essays which document various aspects of the relative intelligence of men and women are Women and the Mismeasure of Thought by Judith Genova, and The Variability Hypothesis by Stephanie Shields. Genova seeks to criticize measuring the difference in intelligence between men and women. Genova was unsuccessful with this article in that the questions she raised were not satisfactorily answered, and there was an overall lack of citation. The Variability Hypothesis is an essay detailing the history and arguments against the purported greater variance in male intelligence. Though the argument of Shields paper is to some extent banal, her criticism of the variability hypothesis is extensive and satisfactory.The introduction of Genovas essay is a criticism of historically accepted measurements of intelligence. In the past using brain size as a measure of intelligence was not altogether unacceptable. When this practice was discredited by the obvious lack of intellectual superiority of whales and elephants, a new physical measure of intelligence was sought. Other body dimensions were given brief consideration as measures of intelligence until the example of Negroes, Australians, and Eskimos denied that theory. Genova argues that prejudice over which groups are socially allowed to be intelligent leads to bad science in determining measures of intelligence. I agree that the highly stereotypical practice of craniometry has no relevance to modern studies of male and female intelligence, though Genova fails to adequately prove the existence of such stereotypes in modern science.Genova cites the example of hemispheric specialization studies as an area of science affected by this same kind of soc...

Page 1 of 6 Next >

    More on On the Relative Intelligence of Women A Review of Two Essays...

    Loading...
 
Copyright © 1999 - 2024 CollegeTermPapers.com. All Rights Reserved. DMCA