Free Will Philosphy
MS. Why is it so necessary for you to consider that whatever happens is somehow ˘necessary÷? How do you account for the behavior of persons who are placed into situations not of their own making?

PH. They will act in a way to conserve themselves (419). I give the example of the thirsty man who can choose to take a drink or not, and ˘in either case, whether he partakes of the water, or whether he does not, the two actions will be equally necessary; they will be the effect of that motive which finds itself most puissant; which consequently acts in the most coercive manner upon his will÷ (419).

MS. You are conflating an issue of physical survival--which has to do with the laws of nature and the human organismĂs need for water--with moral choice. A drink of water, except in a condition in extremis, does not rise to the level of moral choice, and any situation in which it does will involve not a shelf of motives floating in a sea of necessity but competing wills.

PH. You are deliberately misunderstanding me. I am saying that natural law is indeed working on the (illusory) will of man and determining his behavior. The individual responds to the force of such law as a motive power. Just because you may not be able to identify the source of the manĂs decision does not mean there isnĂt one. You must ˘recur[] back [and] . . . perceive[] the multiplied, the compli

    Some topics in this essay  
    MS ThatĂs | PH Surely | PH God | MS Curious | System Nature | Louis XVI | MS ItĂs | | MS Absence | human experience | Schlick Moritz | ph king realize | cause motive | moral choice | act impulse | ph act | ph havenĂt | action act | human agency | nature human | ph king |  
    Get Better Grades!  
    Saved Papers  
    Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!  
"I've used this site for 2 semesters and I'll be back next year for sure!"
Liz R.
"This site rocks! I got an A thanks to you helping with my writers block."
Sara B.
"I was in a real bind and your site helped me to come up with ideas for my paper."
Brian T.
"It's nice to be able to find information so quickly and easily."
Jillian T.
"I enjoy reading other writers papers to get their perspective on things. It makes writing my own paper so much easier."
Cindy A.
Copyright © 1999 - 2014 All Rights Reserved. DMCA