Freedom in a 'State of Nature'
He would be condemned and no doubt put to death for such a crime. Even though his motive for committing the murder was in the public interest, murder is still murder in a civil society, and cannot be condoned under any circumstances.

Rousseau believed that freedom, rationality, and morality are only possible in civil society, and civil society is only possible if the people agree to a civil contract (Sparknotes). We are only human if we are active participants in society. If the only way to be fully human is under a social contract, the contract becomes more important than the individuals who agree to it, and those individuals only have value if they agree to the contract. The contract is not agreed to individually be each person, but is affirmed by the group collectively, making the group more important than the individual. The sovereign and the general will are more important than its subjects and their wills. General will may direct the state to achieve the goals of the common good, and sovereignty is indivisible and inalienable (Halsall).

Though Rousseau believed that rationality and morality were only possible in a civil society, he also believed in a man retaining his individual freedom and not losing his individual power, which gives a mixed message as to how he would regard John's killing of the old man. On the one hand, being part of a civil society, with morality and rationality, he would be condemned, while on the other, exerting his own p

Related Essays

Freedom without Accountability
.... A person who has real freedom is not accountable for his doings. Humankind in its natural state in nature enjoyed such freedoms. .... (759 3 )
John Locke's Thinking About America in Earliest Times
.... This is how he believes that people lived in the earliest times. In the state of nature, according to Locke, people lived in "perfect freedom to (1886 8 )
The Songs of Freedom
An essay or paper on The Songs of Freedom. The state of all beings, including humans, in nature is free. When individuals join societies .... (770 3 )
    Some topics in this essay  
    Zunjic Kant | Halsall Conditions | Halsall Rousseau | Kant John | Sparknotes Rousseau | Contract Rousseau | Morality Rousseau | Social Contract | Immanuel Groundwork | civil society | social contract | Immanuel Kant | moral law | apr 2005 | 3 apr 2005 | 3 apr | moral law zunjic | human nature | world understanding | john's killing | society morality | own personal | rationality morality civil | morality civil society |  
    Get Better Grades!  
    Saved Papers  
    Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!  
"I was in a real bind and your site helped me to come up with ideas for my paper."
Brian T.
"It's nice to be able to find information so quickly and easily."
Jillian T.
"I enjoy reading other writers papers to get their perspective on things. It makes writing my own paper so much easier."
Cindy A.
"I've used this site for 2 semesters and I'll be back next year for sure!"
Liz R.
"This site rocks! I got an A thanks to you helping with my writers block."
Sara B.
Copyright © 1999 - 2014 All Rights Reserved. DMCA