Justice Scalia
2) This case may not afford the judge an opportunity to make new law re cloning because it is not an issue which needs to be decided to dispose of the manslaughter indictment. What the judge does have to decide is whether a cloned embryo of that age is a person who has been killed, a quite different issue than whether cloning is illegal or unconstitutional. Anything he would decide re cloning would be dicta not central to the ruling in the case and, therefore, not a controlling precedent. A judge's common law authority extends only as far as the facts of the case warrant. Judges are notoriously reluctant to decide issues, especially thorny constitutional issues, when they need not to dispose of the case. The District Court should have brought an action, criminal or civil, which directly contests the validity of cloning.

If the judge were to decide the legality of cloning on these facts and in the absence of a governing statute, he really would be taking on a very political role and imposing his own personal values rather than that of the nation's elected representatives. If he did so, he would have to hang his hat on some rubric in the state or federal Constitution, such the 5th/14th Amendment's strictures against the state taking life, liberty or property without due process of law. The difficulty with this approach is that only

    Some topics in this essay  
    Eighth Amendment | James Landis | Professor Wood's | Views Scalia | Constitutional Court | Views Dworkin | Tribe Scalia | Protection Clause | Thomas Jefferson | Views Tribe's | common law | constitutional interpretation | scalia's approach | statutory interpretation | scalia's view | meaning law | equal protection clause | semantic intention | scalia's views | bill rights | matter interpretation | federalist paper 78 | mcculloch maryland 17 | rules statutory construction | common law judges |  
    Get Better Grades!  
    Saved Papers  
    Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!  
"I was in a real bind and your site helped me to come up with ideas for my paper."
Brian T.
"It's nice to be able to find information so quickly and easily."
Jillian T.
"I enjoy reading other writers papers to get their perspective on things. It makes writing my own paper so much easier."
Cindy A.
"I've used this site for 2 semesters and I'll be back next year for sure!"
Liz R.
"This site rocks! I got an A thanks to you helping with my writers block."
Sara B.
Copyright © 1999 - 2014 CollegeTermPapers.com. All Rights Reserved. DMCA