We're Losing the Drug War Considering Forbiddance Never Works
He relies on the audience's sense of values (that it is undesirable to be in a drugged state, that selling and using drugs are crimes and crime is undesirable, that corruption of public officials is undesirable), but he carefully avoids the contrary value---that the legalization of drugs flies in the face of the moral code of the nation. These general and specific weaknesses and failings in Carter's argument make it unlikely that he has persuaded many readers to favor legalization.

Carter's argument that the illegality of drugs and the accompanying "war" on drugs leads to the corruption of law enforcement officials is typical of the essay in terms of both its effectiveness and its fallacies:

Al Capone would have been proud of the latitude that bootleggers were able to buy with their payoffs of constables, deputies, police chiefs, and sheriffs across the state. But . . . Prohibition-era corruption . . . was penny ante stuff compared with what is happening in the United States today. From Brooklyn police precincts to Miami's police stations to rural Georgia courthouses, . . . sheriffs, other policemen, and now judges are being bought up by the gross (9).

Worse, drug money "is also buying up banks, legitimate businesses and, to the south of us, entire government

 

---despite the fact that the cost of heroin for the street user has dropped through the years. This of course is not an argument for continuing prohibition, for the problems of prohibition extend far beyond levels of use. High levels of drug-associated violent crime and crushing pressure on the law enforcement and judicial systems are two important products of drug prohibition which have nothing to do with levels of drug use.

Carter argues that illegal drugs create an incentive for individual Americans to participate in the drug trade because of the money involved. He presents data based on unmentioned sources, but, again, the audience he addresses is so immersed in such statistics that few would likely question the statistics. He may be exaggerating, but there is no doubt in America that poor inner-city youths are tempted by drug money. He writes:

leaves the lingering and legitimate fear that legalization might produce a surge in use. It probably would, although not nearly as dramatic a one as opponents usually estimate (10).

Since the courts and jails are already swamped beyond capacity by the arrests that are routinely made (44,000 drug dealers and users over a two-year period in Washington alone), and since those arrests barely skim the top of the pond, arguing that stricter enforcement is the answer begs a larger question: Who is going to pay the billions of dollars required [for such an expanded law enforcement effort]? (10).

Carter does not evade the question of the negative effects of legalization of drugs, although perhaps he minimizes those possible effects. He admits that his argument for legalization up to this point still

Again, by simply raising quickly and dismissing this likely rise in drug use after legalization, Carter fails to deal directly and effectively with the major protest against that legalization. If Carter wants to persuade his readers and change minds to support his position, he should have taken advantage of the opportunit

 
2536
10
 
   
 
 
   
    Some topics in this essay  
 
    United Brooklyn | War Prohibition | Al Capone | war drugs | law enforcement | legalization drugs | carter's argument | illegal drugs | Journal July | argument legalization | violent crime | carter's essay | legalization carter's | rise drug | Losing Drug | III We're | We're Losing | Drug War | war drugs effective | losing drug war | corruption law enforcement | increased law enforcement | drug war prohibition |  
   
 
 
 
   
    Get Better Grades!  
 
   
 
   
 
   
    Saved Papers  
 
    Save your essays here so you can locate them quickly!  
   
 
   
    Testimonials  
 
   
"I enjoy reading other writers papers to get their perspective on things. It makes writing my own paper so much easier."
Cindy A.
 
"I've used this site for 2 semesters and I'll be back next year for sure!"
Liz R.
 
"This site rocks! I got an A thanks to you helping with my writers block."
Sara B.
 
"I was in a real bind and your site helped me to come up with ideas for my paper."
Brian T.
 
"It's nice to be able to find information so quickly and easily."
Jillian T.
 
 
   
 
 
Copyright © 1999 - 2013 CollegeTermPapers.com. All Rights Reserved. DMCA